Skip To Content
  • Home
  • Property Listings
  • Buxton Surf Shack Hits the Market: A Classic Coastal Cottage Just Steps from the Beach

Buxton Surf Shack Hits the Market: A Classic Coastal Cottage Just Steps from the Beach

Looking for an affordable, investment-friendly Outer Banks property in a high-demand beach town? Welcome to 46084 Cottage Ave, Buxton, NC

57036 Lighthouse Court, Hatteras, NC

This laid-back Buxton surf shack has everything you need for sun, surf, and solid rental potential. If you’ve been dreaming about owning a piece of the Outer Banks, this charming beach cottage in Buxton might be the one you’ve been waiting for. Offered by Trisha Midgett and Team, this colorful gem is just a few lots back from the ocean and located in the heart of one of the most sought-after coastal towns on the East Coast.

Why Buxton is a Smart Investment

Buxton is more than just a beach town—it’s the East Coast’s premier surf destination and home to Cape Hatteras Point, a world-famous fishing hotspot that draws outdoor lovers year-round. The consistent tourism traffic, laid-back lifestyle, and limited inventory make Buxton a wise choice for investors seeking a vacation rental or a second home with long-term value.

Coastal Charm with a Laid-Back Vibe

This classic cottage has everything you need for that easy Outer Banks lifestyle. Inside, you’ll find charming wood paneling, colorful beachy decor, and cozy living spaces that bring back nostalgic summer memories. The sunroom and screened porch are perfect spots to soak in the salty breeze or enjoy a peaceful morning coffee.

The shaded area underneath the home offers an outdoor shower, picnic table, swing, and hammock—ideal for post-beach hangs or grilling out after a day on the water.

Bonus: there’s ample yard space, a paved driveway, and low-maintenance landscaping, making this home a great option for hassle-free ownership.

Walk or Bike to Everything

Location is everything, and this cottage delivers. You’re within walking or biking distance to:

  • Cape Hatteras Lighthouse
  • Local restaurants and coffee shops
  • Surf shops and gear rentals
  • Buxton’s beloved arcade and ice cream spots
  • Cape Point for legendary surf and fishing

This kind of convenience is rare on Hatteras Island—and it’s exactly what makes this home a strong contender for vacation rental success.

Whether you’re an investor looking for a profitable beach rental or a buyer craving a low-key surf retreat, this Buxton cottage offers an unbeatable combination of charm, location, and value.

Don’t miss your chance to own a piece of the Outer Banks in one of its most iconic surf towns. Contact Trisha Midgett and Team today to schedule your private showing or learn more about the rental income potential this property offers.

46084 Cottage Ave, Buxton
46084 Cottage Ave, Buxton

Trisha Midgett

Hi, I’m Trisha Midgett, broker-in-charge at Midgett Realty and the lead agent of Trisha Midgett & Team, a top-producing real estate team on the Outer Banks. I’ve been helping buyers, sellers, and investors navigate the Outer Banks real estate market for over 30 years, with a strong focus on Hatteras Island and the surrounding OBX communities. From oceanfront vacation homes to second homes and investment properties, my team and I work across the entire Outer Banks, including Nags Head, Kill Devil Hills, Kitty Hawk, Manteo, Corolla, and Ocracoke. In 2024, our team closed 212 transactions, followed by 181 transactions in 2025, reflecting a consistent track record of results in a unique coastal market. I specialize in second homes, vacation properties, short-term rental and investment real estate, and seller strategy, helping clients understand pricing, rental potential, and long-term value. With decades of experience on the Outer Banks, I bring deep local knowledge of neighborhoods, rental dynamics, and market trends to every transaction. Clients often tell me they appreciate my honest advice, fast communication, strong negotiation skills, and laid-back, easy-to-work-with approach. I’m honored to have earned over 450 five-star reviews on Zillow, 220+ Google reviews, 171 five-star Homes.com reviews, 122 five-star FastExpert reviews, and a 5-star rating on Realtor.com, with verified transaction history publicly displayed. I’ve also been recognized as one of America’s Top 100 Real Estate Agents™ for North Carolina, received HomeLight Top Producer and Top Negotiator Awards, and earned Outer Banks Coastal Life Readers’ Choice Best Real Estate Team honors. Whether you’re buying your first beach cottage, selling a vacation rental, or investing in a second home on Hatteras Island or anywhere on the Outer Banks, my team and I are here to guide you every step of the way and make the process as smooth and successful as possible.
Comments are closed.
<-- Client Provided November 20, 2019-->